Insurance dispute leaves W. Seneca girl without life-saving treatment coverage
WEST SENECA, N.Y. (WKBW) — A 22-month-old girl, Sophia Watson, is in urgent need of life-saving treatment for a tumor, but an insurance dispute has left her family without coverage.
Sophia, who has neurofibromatosis type 1, has a tumor on her optic nerves that requires treatment with an oral chemotherapy drug called Mekinist.
“It is inoperable. We were told that it is pretty much a 100% chance that if they operate on it, she will go blind because of the placement of the ocular nerve,” said Benjamin Watson.
Her parents, Benjamin and Amanda Watson, are facing a significant financial burden after their insurance provider, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, denied coverage for the medication.
“We’re doing everything we can. We’re going about everything the best way possible or what we think is the best way but it’s difficult. It’s very tough. It’s very draining, mentally, physically,” the father said.
Sophia’s treatment plan involves taking Mekinist once a day for two years, which has kept her tumor stable. However, due to the insurance denial, the family of five now has to pay $1,800 per bottle, requiring two bottles per month. Her dosage increases, the other she gets.
The denial came after Benjamin Watson changed jobs, which resulted in a switch in insurance providers. Since then, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, along with Express Scripts, have not provided coverage for the drug.
When I reached out to Anthem BCBS, a public relations director said the prescription benefit manager it works with, Express Scripts, was responsible for the denial.
The insurance company released the following statement:
“While Anthem provides medical benefits through the member’s employer, in this case, the employer chose to use Express Scripts as their pharmacy benefit manager. We are not affiliated with the member’s pharmacy benefit manager, nor do we have any decision-making authority in this matter. Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield works to ensure our members receive integrated, connected care, and we assisted the member in connecting to their correct pharmacy benefit manager for more information on the medications in question.”
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
I also reached out to Express Scripts for clarification. A customer service representative told me the company no longer has a media department but said Express Scripts follows the coverage criteria set by insurance companies and that it was the insurance company that denied coverage.
Sophia’s parents said Roswell Park Comprehensive Cancer Center has submitted an expedited appeal and a peer-to-peer review with Express Scripts. I reached out to Roswell Park for confirmation and am awaiting a response.
While Sophia’s family navigates the insurance challenges, they are seeking support through a GoFundMe to help cover the medication costs.
Copyright 2025 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
A Voice For Everyone
We want to hear what’s going on in your community. Share your voice and hear from your neighbors.